22 Comments
User's avatar
Daniel Gorsky's avatar

Thanks Dylan. I'm also paper-and-pencil and see the benefit of paper and pencil and verbal practice over getting kids on screens to practice fact fluency.

My team of teachers was looking for something to use to practice outside of the classroom to start the school year.

Thanks for sharing this knowledge and starting this conversation.

Hannah B Whitaker's avatar

"At a basic level, what I’m sharing are a bunch of pieces of paper with math problems on them." Hehe, love bringing the call a spade a spade tone back into educational discourse.

(Also, was going to suggest mixing up the formatting __ = fact problem and a missing part format- but someone beat me to it!)

We use the Math for Love flashcard boxes for lots of daily practice - they are brilliant, but expensive for a class set, good possibility for station work though. Excellent examples of ways to visualize the strategies for students who need that support.

Seth's avatar

This is fantastic! Thank you so much for sharing the resources!

I think the solution to the anxiety thing is... well, there isn't one, generally, the world is just a big confusing place and children are very small. But I think it helps to try to let everyone have an opportunity to "win". To feel like, wherever they are, they are capable of making meaningful progress, and that that progress will be celebrated.

The problem, of course, is that that's an unreasonable amount of work. It seems like LLMs should be useful for constructing differentiated "winnable" obstacles for each student, though easier said than done of course.

Incidentally, the easiest way to get reliable outputs on long, repetitive tasks from an LLM is to tell them to do what you did, which is write a python script!

Kristen Smith's avatar

Thanks for sharing all the resources! I would love to have our 6th and 7th grade teachers use these.

Evidence Matters's avatar

Love that you are making these available!!!

Bill McCallum's avatar

What I like about this is the thought put into structure and sequencing. Worksheets can have a hidden conceptual agenda, so to speak.

Dylan Kane's avatar

Yes they definitely can. Something I'm perpetually conflicted about is that most teachers I know dislike anything that feels like a worksheet. Stuff like this is easy to misuse: you print it, put it in front of kids, and call it a day. That's not going to do much work on the conceptual side. So I get the issues with worksheets. But the reality is, in whole-class instruction, with kids at a range of levels, we need a significant amount of practice. If you're allergic to worksheets that practice becomes easy to overlook, but worksheets are easy to misuse. No easy solution.

Rachael Nicholson's avatar

Hi Dylan, its been a while since you made this post. During this time I have been moving my grade 1 daughter through the worksheets at home. She gets an addition, subtraction and multiplication worksheet when we do this of an evening. Im not super consistent, life gets busy.

For background information she has not been formally taught multiplication at school yet. Also, the school has moved away from tasks that involve memorising math facts (as I think many have), which is why I'm adding the extra practice at home. This resource has been amazing so far so thank you for sharing.

An interesting thing happened last night that I want to share and get your thoughts. I taught my daughter 5 times tables for the first time. The 2s and 10s were a great place to start, she has done plenty of skip counting. She has also learnt to skip count in 5s, but I presumed this worksheet might take a bit longer for her to complete quickly. We did some very quick preliminary work using the times table poster in her room, some choral response, noticing patters, asking her what strategy she might use if she gets stuck on 12X6 (i.e remember 10X6 and skip count up). Then I gave her the worksheet, expecting average memory recall due to limited exposure, frustration and complaining. But she finished it super fast, without making a sound!

I asked her how she did it, even checked for cheating lol. But turns out she learnt how to game the worksheet. The first question was 4X5 =20. She advised she then found every version of 4X5 and 5X4 and quickly wrote in 20. Next was 3X5=15, so she worked that one out and then again populated every version of this on the worksheet.

I was impressed. It was clever and efficient.

But .. do you think she will push these to long term memory by doing it this way or should I enforce one at a time so that each question out of the 60 requires a more effortful retrieval ? Or maybe I let her do this approach for a few sheets to build familiarity and then challenge her to go one by one?

Thanks

Rach

Dylan Kane's avatar

Great question. I see students do this and I discourage it. I may allow it for the first time through if I really want students to build confidence but I think the interleaving makes a big difference for building that long-term memory.

Something I do to help with this is I don’t go in a totally linear way through the worksheets. I’ll do a blocked version, then an interleaved version and see how it goes, then back to the blocked version. That helps to avoid students gaming the system. But at a certain point I just need to say no, you have to do these in order.

Rachael Nicholson's avatar

Ahh.. mixing between block and interleaved makes sense. To date I have been doing block (5 sheets) then interleaved (5 sheets) …

Thanks for clarifying my suspicions, I need to ensure she goes one at a time.

Thanks!

Lesley's avatar

This is neat! Have you considered stacking the problems vertically instead of presenting them horizontally? Because my students get confused when it comes to subtraction -- they think if the subtrahend is bigger than the minuend, they can just swap them out. An antidote for this would be to present more problems vertically, so they understand that the minuend is fixed and can't be changed.

Dylan Kane's avatar

This is something I thought about and unfortunately it is beyond my typesetting skills, I generated these programmatically and I don't know how to set that up in a way where all the problems fit and everything looks nice and neat. Another benefit of the vertical approach is avoiding misconceptions around the equals sign, which can become a problem further down the road.

I'm not sure how much this matters. I would prefer vertical but not by a huge margin so I decided it was fine as is. I definitely see the subtraction problem when we get to negatives and it is an annoying one to work through, though I don't know that reorienting vertically eliminates it.

Peter's avatar

This is really great. As another commented, I love the thoughtfulness that goes into the worksheets and especially the connections (28-4 as a part of the x4 unit). I teach high school students, many of whom with fact fluency, and I struggle to know where/how to introduce this amongst the 1000 other things to teach them. Additionally, there is a level of shame for kids learning these that I have to navigate.

One more thing: My elementary school-age children are explicitly taught number bonds 17 + 9 = 17 + (3 + 6) = (17 + 3) + 6. It is new math-y, but it is how most strong mathematicians do those problems and it has extensions for time (proctor a 50 minute test that starts at 9:48 - very few mathematicians are lining up and carrying) and negative numbers (-3 + 16 = -3 + (3 + 13)). Have you experimented with these at all?

Dylan Kane's avatar

Yea I was torn about those number bonds because it's hard to practice them in this format. Would all the questions be 3 + 7, 6 + 4, 8 + 2? Then students won't be thinking, just copying 10 every time. I messed around with a few options but couldn't come up with something I liked. That type of instruction should definitely be something students experience but it didn't fit with this model of practice.

The shame in upper grades is real, I see plenty of it in 7th. I don't know the best way to move past it beyond just trying to help students learn more.

Daniel Gorsky's avatar

Is there a computer based program thar people recommend for at home practice for fact fluency?

One the supports students with strategies if they don't know some of their facts and doesn't simply mark problems as incorrect?

Dylan Kane's avatar

I'm a paper-and-pencil guy so I can't vouch for any firsthand. Another commenter mentioned MathFactLab - I tested that myself a few years ago and thought it was really well-designed though I don't remember all the details. My experience is that most programs lean either one way or the other, i.e. FactFreaks is pure practice, no strategies, while Amplify's Fluency by Heart leans hard on representations but provides less practice.

Ashley Baker's avatar

Math Fact Lab has students practice along a trajectory that your taking about (which is what Dr. Nicki Newton, Sangiovanni, and Bay-Williams give resources to do as well). Math Fact Lab gives a timed assessments, but it is timing by fact (how long each fact took the student). We also use running records (Newton) to follow up and make sure students have efficient strategies that will lead not only to long term memory but also long term use in the structure of Math.

I have been using structured (to 5 and 10) arrays with high success for intervention to support students to see the commutative property and division relationships. We play a game and gradually start screening (blocking the array to see if students can make the array mental and use relationships when needed, i.e 5 x5 is 25 so 6x5 is 30 or 30 divided by 6 is 5 because 6 x 5 is 30). I make sure students can explain the "why" in these stages beyond counting using relationships.

Dylan Kane's avatar

I've played around with Math Fact Lab and I think it does some things really well, but I'm looking for something using pencil and paper for my students.

I like the use of arrays for the commutative property - I do a bit of that using number talks. I have found that more practice is needed for students to really become automatic, though.

Ashley Baker's avatar

Yes, I don't use it as a sole fluency resource and I don't think they recommend that. We do explicit and targeted fact practice based from the assessments and running records as well as games that encourage speed.

Julie Pottinger's avatar

Thank you for sharing! I started following you after reading your first post about incremental fact fluency. I was intrigued by it, but so far, have had trouble finding time for it. After doing a small amount of work around multiplication facts at the end of the year, I have committed to start next year more intentionally. I appreciate your thoughts on the timing debate. I share your concerns that timing may actually limit practice for those who need it most. I think it can also lead to students to employ strategies that improve their speed without improving their fact knowledge (writing more quickly, doing the easy problems first, etc.) I did a research study on the effectiveness of timed math fact tests over 20 years ago. Perhaps one day I will share more about it in detail, but one of the most interesting findings was that the timed math fact tests often painted an inaccurate or incomplete picture of students' actual fact knowledge. For both the pre and post tests, I gave students a timed fact assessment. However, I also assessed students individually using flash cards (Scores were based on number correct in less than 3 seconds per fact). There was a surprising lack of correlation between students' scores on these two assessments.

Dylan Kane's avatar

That's interesting! While I don't have that experience, I have definitely seen proficiency levels vary from one context to another. Finding time is a real challenge and means accepting some tradeoffs, but I just think there's no way around it. Either fact fluency is important or it's not, and if it's important there are no shortcuts. This is where some thoughtful coordination between grades can be really helpful though, prioritizing fluency with different operations in different grades and dividing up the work so it's more manageable. That's not the case where I work now but I can imagine it would be really helpful.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 27
Comment deleted
Dylan Kane's avatar

Yes those are really valuable! I mix in a lot of those as I teach a bunch of equation solving, but on a more piecemeal basis. Would be interesting to make another set of practice handouts for those types of variations.